Which should I choose?

I was recently gifted an Amazon gift card from a friend and so obviously I went on amazon.com to look for some shoes. I love shoooeees heeheee. I've narrowed my choices down to two pairs. Which ones do you like better?

Not going to lie, I'm pretty torn right now. I like the cream color, but its going to get dirty easily. But I feel like I would feel more secure in the shoe. I love the taupe color and I love the detailing of the other one. I feel like I could get more wear out of it simply because its a pump shape and so I can wear it with longer pants. What do you think?